{
  "id": "cegep_esl_progression_en",
  "language": "en",
  "domain": "cegep_esl_evaluation_progression",
  "levels": [
    {
      "levelKey": "level_1",
      "labelByLanguage": {
        "en": "Level 1"
      },
      "cefrLabel": "A2+",
      "skillGroups": [
        {
          "skillKey": "oral_interaction",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Oral Interaction"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_oral_clarity_coherence",
              "criterionKey": "clarity_and_coherence",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Clarity and Coherence"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Expresses ideas clearly and coherently with appropriate transition words."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_clarity_coherence_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the situation or communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_clarity_coherence_1a",
                  "indicatorKey": "clear_expression_familiar_topics",
                  "code": "1a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Clear, generally coherent expression of intentions, emotions, opinions, simple descriptions, or narratives on familiar, everyday topics that are socially or culturally relevant."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_clarity_coherence_1d",
                  "indicatorKey": "interaction_with_occasional_support",
                  "code": "1d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Interaction without major difficulty, taking initiative when appropriate, with occasional support, in routine and predictable situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_clarity_coherence_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_grammatical_forms_and_some_complex_structures",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of simple grammatical forms and some frequently used complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_clarity_coherence_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "sufficient_everyday_vocabulary",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of sufficient everyday vocabulary to communicate."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_oral_participation_interaction_responses",
              "criterionKey": "participation_interaction_strategies_and_responses",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Participation, Interaction Strategies, and Responses"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Engages in the interaction, uses strategies (questioning, clarifying, showing interest), and responds in ways that contribute meaningfully to the exchange."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_interaction_strategies",
                  "code": "1e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of strategies to ensure understanding and to keep the interaction going."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1b",
                  "indicatorKey": "questions_and_answers",
                  "code": "1b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Simple, generally coherent formulation of questions and answers during interactions."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1c",
                  "indicatorKey": "adequate_relevant_reactions",
                  "code": "1c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Generally adequate, relevant reactions and responses to what the other person says."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1d",
                  "indicatorKey": "interaction_with_occasional_support",
                  "code": "1d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Interaction without major difficulty, taking initiative when appropriate, with occasional support in routine and predictable situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_participation_interaction_responses_0g",
                  "indicatorKey": "active_effective_collaboration",
                  "code": "0g",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Active and effective collaboration."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_participation_interaction_responses_0f",
                  "indicatorKey": "openness_respect_curiosity",
                  "code": "0f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of openness, respect, and curiosity toward other cultures."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_oral_language_comprehensibility",
              "criterionKey": "language_and_comprehensibility",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Language and Comprehensibility"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Pronunciation, grammar, and vocabulary are clear enough to be understood by interlocutors despite some difficulties."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_language_comprehensibility_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_grammatical_forms_and_some_complex_structures",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of simple grammatical forms and some frequently used complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_language_comprehensibility_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "sufficient_everyday_vocabulary",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of sufficient everyday vocabulary to communicate."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_language_comprehensibility_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital online resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and correction."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_language_comprehensibility_1f",
                  "indicatorKey": "pronunciation_clear_enough",
                  "code": "1f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Pronunciation clear enough to be understood despite occasional difficulties."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_oral_progress_feedback",
              "criterionKey": "demonstrates_progress_based_on_strategies_and_feedback",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Demonstrates Progress Based on Strategies and Feedback"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Shows evidence of using feedback (peer, teacher, AI) and applying appropriate learning strategies to improve interaction over time."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_progress_feedback_1g",
                  "indicatorKey": "evident_progress_oral_skills",
                  "code": "1g",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Evident progress in oral skills based on strategies and feedback."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_progress_feedback_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "self_regulated_learning_strategies",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote second-language autonomy."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_oral_progress_feedback_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital online resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and correction."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "skillKey": "writing_process",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Writing Process"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_writing_content_organization_coherence",
              "criterionKey": "content_organization_coherence",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Content, Organization, and Coherence"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Chooses and organizes ideas appropriately to communicate a clear, coherent message adapted to the purpose and audience."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_content_organization_coherence_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_content_organization_coherence_2a",
                  "indicatorKey": "appropriate_selection_of_ideas",
                  "code": "2a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate selection of ideas relevant to the topic in routine writing situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_content_organization_coherence_2b",
                  "indicatorKey": "appropriate_planning_and_organization",
                  "code": "2b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate planning and organization of ideas."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_content_organization_coherence_2c",
                  "indicatorKey": "short_texts_familiar_topics",
                  "code": "2c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Writing short texts on familiar, everyday topics that are socially or culturally relevant."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_content_organization_coherence_2d",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_coherent_expression_with_transitions",
                  "code": "2d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Simple, generally coherent expression of intentions, emotions, opinions, descriptions, or narratives, linking statements with simple transition words."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_writing_process_revision",
              "criterionKey": "writing_process_and_revision",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Writing Process and Revision"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses feedback and writing strategies to improve content, structure, and clarity."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_process_revision_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "self_regulated_learning_strategies",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote second-language autonomy."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_process_revision_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital online resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and correction."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_process_revision_2e",
                  "indicatorKey": "identify_and_correct_basic_errors",
                  "code": "2e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of appropriate strategies to identify and correct errors related to basic spelling, grammar, syntax, and punctuation rules."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_process_revision_2f",
                  "indicatorKey": "evident_progress_writing",
                  "code": "2f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Evident progress in writing skills based on feedback."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_writing_language_use",
              "criterionKey": "language_use",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Language Use (Accuracy and Range)"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses language forms (grammar, verb tenses, vocabulary) appropriate to the task and A2+ level."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_language_use_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_grammatical_forms_and_some_complex_structures",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of simple grammatical forms and some frequently used complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_language_use_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "sufficient_everyday_vocabulary",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of sufficient everyday vocabulary to communicate."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_writing_language_use_2e",
                  "indicatorKey": "correct_basic_errors",
                  "code": "2e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of appropriate strategies to identify and correct errors related to basic spelling, grammar, syntax, and punctuation."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "skillKey": "reinvestment",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Reinvestment"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_reinvestment_use_of_strategies",
              "criterionKey": "use_of_strategies",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Use of Strategies"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses learned strategies (e.g., annotation, note-taking, dictionary use, mind mapping, etc.) to process the text and identify useful ideas."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "self_regulated_learning_strategies",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote second-language autonomy."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital online resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and correction."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_3a",
                  "indicatorKey": "appropriate_reading_listening_strategies",
                  "code": "3a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of appropriate use of reading or listening strategies, taking into account the purpose and potential obstacles to reading or listening."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_reinvestment_processing",
              "criterionKey": "processing",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Processing"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Selects main and supporting ideas or components from the source text that are relevant for reinvestment."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_reinvestment_processing_3b",
                  "indicatorKey": "accurate_processing_of_ideas",
                  "code": "3b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Accurate processing, in oral or written form, of the components or the main and supporting ideas of texts on familiar, everyday topics of social or cultural relevance."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l1_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas",
              "criterionKey": "reinvestment_of_new_and_creative_ideas",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Reinvestment of New and Creative Ideas"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Integrates new ideas and/or opinions with coherence, showing understanding of the source text and adapting to the communicative context."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the situation or communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_3c",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_expression_of_new_ideas",
                  "code": "3c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Simple oral or written expression of opinions and new, creative ideas, drawing on elements from the source text."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l1_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_3d",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_generally_coherent_response_text",
                  "code": "3d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Production of a simple, generally coherent oral, written, or media text in response to the source text, while respecting the components of the communication context."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },

    {
      "levelKey": "level_2",
      "labelByLanguage": {
        "en": "Level 2"
      },
      "cefrLabel": "B1",
      "skillGroups": [
        {
          "skillKey": "oral_interaction",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Oral Interaction"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_oral_clarity_coherence",
              "criterionKey": "clarity_and_coherence",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Clarity and Coherence"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Expresses ideas clearly and coherently, with some ease, organizing discourse logically and using appropriate transition words to connect ideas."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_clarity_coherence_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the situation or communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_clarity_coherence_1a",
                  "indicatorKey": "clear_coherent_expression",
                  "code": "1a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Clear and coherent expression of intentions, emotions, opinions, descriptions, narratives, or explanations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_clarity_coherence_1d",
                  "indicatorKey": "spontaneous_interaction_some_ease",
                  "code": "1d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Spontaneous interaction with some ease in predictable and less predictable situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_clarity_coherence_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_grammatical_forms_and_common_complex_structures",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of simple grammatical forms as well as commonly used complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_clarity_coherence_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "varied_everyday_vocabulary_with_some_abstract_terms",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of a varied range of everyday, concrete vocabulary, along with some abstract terms."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_oral_participation_interaction_responses",
              "criterionKey": "participation_interaction_strategies_and_responses",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Participation, Interaction Strategies, and Responses"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Engages actively in the interaction with some ease, uses appropriate interaction strategies (e.g., questioning, clarifying, showing interest), and responds in ways that support and sustain the exchange."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_interaction_strategies",
                  "code": "1e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of strategies to ensure understanding and to maintain interaction."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1b",
                  "indicatorKey": "questions_and_answers",
                  "code": "1b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Simple and coherent formulation of questions and answers during interactions."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1c",
                  "indicatorKey": "adequate_relevant_reactions",
                  "code": "1c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Adequate and relevant reactions and responses to what the other person says."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1d",
                  "indicatorKey": "spontaneous_interaction_some_ease",
                  "code": "1d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Spontaneous interaction with some ease in predictable and less predictable situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_participation_interaction_responses_0g",
                  "indicatorKey": "active_effective_collaboration",
                  "code": "0g",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Active and effective collaboration."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_participation_interaction_responses_0f",
                  "indicatorKey": "openness_respect_curiosity",
                  "code": "0f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of openness, respect, and curiosity toward other cultures."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_oral_language_comprehensibility",
              "criterionKey": "language_and_comprehensibility",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Language and Comprehensibility"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Pronunciation, grammar, and vocabulary are generally clear and understandable, allowing interlocutors to follow meaning with little effort despite occasional difficulties."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_language_comprehensibility_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_grammatical_forms_and_common_complex_structures",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of simple grammatical forms as well as commonly used complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_language_comprehensibility_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "varied_everyday_vocabulary_with_some_abstract_terms",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of a varied range of everyday, concrete vocabulary, along with some abstract terms."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_language_comprehensibility_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_language_comprehensibility_1f",
                  "indicatorKey": "generally_clear_pronunciation",
                  "code": "1f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Generally clear and understandable pronunciation despite occasional difficulties."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_oral_progress_feedback",
              "criterionKey": "demonstrates_progress_based_on_strategies_and_feedback",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Demonstrates Progress Based on Strategies and Feedback"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Shows clear evidence of using feedback (from peers, the teacher, and digital tools such as AI) and applying appropriate learning strategies to improve oral interaction with some consistency over time."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_progress_feedback_1g",
                  "indicatorKey": "evident_progress_oral_skills",
                  "code": "1g",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Evident progress in oral skills based on strategies and feedback."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_progress_feedback_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "self_regulated_learning_strategies",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote autonomy in the second language."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_oral_progress_feedback_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "skillKey": "writing_process",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Writing Process"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_writing_content_organization_coherence",
              "criterionKey": "content_organization_coherence",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Content, Organization, and Coherence"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Selects and organizes ideas appropriately to communicate a clear and coherent message adapted to the purpose and audience, with logical development of ideas."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_content_organization_coherence_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_content_organization_coherence_2a",
                  "indicatorKey": "appropriate_choice_of_ideas",
                  "code": "2a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate choice of ideas that fit the writing topic in varied and less predictable situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_content_organization_coherence_2b",
                  "indicatorKey": "appropriate_planning_and_organization",
                  "code": "2b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate planning and organization of ideas."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_content_organization_coherence_2c",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_coherent_texts_everyday_topics",
                  "code": "2c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Writing simple, coherent texts on everyday topics of social or cultural relevance."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_content_organization_coherence_2d",
                  "indicatorKey": "coherent_expression_with_transitions",
                  "code": "2d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Coherent expression of intentions, emotions, opinions, descriptions, narratives, and explanations, generally using appropriate, logical transition words."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_writing_process_revision",
              "criterionKey": "writing_process_and_revision",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Writing Process and Revision"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses feedback and writing strategies with some consistency to revise and improve content, organization, and clarity throughout the writing process."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_process_revision_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "self_regulated_learning_strategies",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote autonomy in the second language."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_process_revision_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_process_revision_2e",
                  "indicatorKey": "identify_and_correct_basic_errors",
                  "code": "2e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of appropriate strategies to identify and correct basic spelling, grammar, syntax, and punctuation errors."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_process_revision_2f",
                  "indicatorKey": "evident_progress_writing",
                  "code": "2f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Evident progress in writing skills based on strategies and feedback."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_writing_language_use",
              "criterionKey": "language_use",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Language Use (Accuracy and Range)"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses grammatical forms, verb tenses, and vocabulary appropriate to the task and Level 2 expectations, allowing meaning to be communicated clearly and coherently despite occasional errors."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_language_use_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "simple_grammatical_forms_and_common_complex_structures",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of simple grammatical forms as well as commonly used complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_language_use_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "varied_everyday_vocabulary_with_some_abstract_terms",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of a varied range of everyday, concrete vocabulary, along with some abstract terms."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_writing_language_use_2e",
                  "indicatorKey": "correct_basic_errors",
                  "code": "2e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of appropriate strategies to identify and correct basic spelling, grammar, syntax, and punctuation errors."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "skillKey": "reinvestment",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Reinvestment"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_reinvestment_use_of_strategies",
              "criterionKey": "use_of_strategies",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Use of Strategies"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses learned reading or listening strategies with some consistency and purpose to process texts and identify relevant ideas for reinvestment."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "self_regulated_learning_strategies",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote autonomy in the second language."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_3a",
                  "indicatorKey": "appropriate_reading_listening_strategies",
                  "code": "3a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of appropriate use of reading or listening strategies, taking into account the purpose and potential obstacles to reading or listening."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_reinvestment_processing",
              "criterionKey": "processing",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Processing"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Selects and processes main and supporting ideas or components from the source text accurately, identifying information or conventions that are relevant for reinvestment."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_reinvestment_processing_3b",
                  "indicatorKey": "accurate_processing_of_ideas",
                  "code": "3b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Accurate processing, in oral or written form, of the components or the main and supporting ideas of texts on familiar, everyday topics of social or cultural relevance."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l2_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas",
              "criterionKey": "reinvestment_of_new_and_creative_ideas",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Reinvestment of New and Creative Ideas"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Integrates new ideas and/or opinions with coherence, showing understanding of the source text and adapting to the communicative context."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the situation or communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_3c",
                  "indicatorKey": "personal_reflections_new_ideas",
                  "code": "3c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Clear oral or written expression of personal reflections and new, creative ideas, drawing on elements from the source text."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l2_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_3d",
                  "indicatorKey": "coherent_response_text",
                  "code": "3d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Production of a simple, coherent oral, written, or media text in response to the source text, while respecting the components of the communication context."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },

    {
      "levelKey": "level_3",
      "labelByLanguage": {
        "en": "Level 3"
      },
      "cefrLabel": "B2",
      "skillGroups": [
        {
          "skillKey": "oral_interaction",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Oral Interaction"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_oral_clarity_coherence",
              "criterionKey": "clarity_and_coherence",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Clarity and Coherence"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Expresses ideas clearly, coherently, and precisely, with fluency, organizing discourse effectively and using appropriate transition words to structure and connect ideas."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_clarity_coherence_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the situation or communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_clarity_coherence_1a",
                  "indicatorKey": "clear_coherent_fluent_expression",
                  "code": "1a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Clear, coherent, and fluent expression of intentions, hypotheses, supported opinions, arguments, narratives, or explanations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_clarity_coherence_1e",
                  "indicatorKey": "fluent_proactive_interaction",
                  "code": "1e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Fluent and proactive interaction in varied, sometimes unpredictable situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_clarity_coherence_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "range_of_grammatical_forms",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of a range of grammatical forms and complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_clarity_coherence_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "varied_vocabulary",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of varied vocabulary to communicate."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_oral_participation_interaction_responses",
              "criterionKey": "participation_interaction_strategies_and_responses",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Participation, Interaction Strategies, and Responses"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Engages actively and proactively in interaction, uses interaction strategies judiciously, and responds fluently and appropriately in ways that sustain and develop the exchange."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1f",
                  "indicatorKey": "judicious_use_of_interaction_strategies",
                  "code": "1f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Judicious use of strategies to ensure understanding and to keep the interaction going."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1c",
                  "indicatorKey": "precise_coherent_questions_answers",
                  "code": "1c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Precise and coherent formulation of questions and answers during interactions."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1d",
                  "indicatorKey": "fluent_relevant_responses",
                  "code": "1d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Generally fluent and relevant reactions and responses to what the other person says."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1e",
                  "indicatorKey": "fluent_proactive_interaction",
                  "code": "1e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Fluent and proactive interaction in varied, sometimes unpredictable situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_participation_interaction_responses_0g",
                  "indicatorKey": "active_effective_collaboration",
                  "code": "0g",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Active and effective collaboration."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_participation_interaction_responses_0f",
                  "indicatorKey": "openness_respect_curiosity",
                  "code": "0f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of openness, respect, and curiosity toward other cultures."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_oral_language_comprehensibility",
              "criterionKey": "language_and_comprehensibility",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Language and Comprehensibility"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Pronunciation, grammar, and vocabulary are clear and precise, supporting fluent comprehension and effective communication, even when addressing moderately complex or abstract topics."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_language_comprehensibility_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "range_of_grammatical_forms",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of a range of grammatical forms and complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_language_comprehensibility_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "varied_vocabulary",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of varied vocabulary to communicate."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_language_comprehensibility_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_language_comprehensibility_1g",
                  "indicatorKey": "clear_precise_pronunciation",
                  "code": "1g",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Clear and precise pronunciation with generally appropriate intonation and pace."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_oral_progress_feedback",
              "criterionKey": "demonstrates_progress_based_on_strategies_and_feedback",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Demonstrates Progress Based on Strategies and Feedback"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Shows consistent and intentional use of feedback and learning strategies to improve oral interaction, with observable progress over time."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_progress_feedback_1h",
                  "indicatorKey": "evident_progress_oral_skills",
                  "code": "1h",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Evident progress in oral skills based on strategies and feedback."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_progress_feedback_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "self_regulated_learning_strategies",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote second-language autonomy."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_oral_progress_feedback_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "skillKey": "writing_process",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Writing Process"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_writing_content_organization_coherence",
              "criterionKey": "content_organization_coherence",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Content, Organization, and Coherence"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Selects, develops, and organizes ideas effectively to communicate a clear, coherent, and well-structured message adapted to the purpose, audience, and topic."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_content_organization_coherence_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_content_organization_coherence_2a",
                  "indicatorKey": "judicious_choice_of_ideas",
                  "code": "2a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Judicious choice of ideas that fit the writing topic in varied, moderately complex situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_content_organization_coherence_2b",
                  "indicatorKey": "effective_planning_and_structure",
                  "code": "2b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Effective and well-reasoned planning of ideas and text structure."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_content_organization_coherence_2c",
                  "indicatorKey": "well_structured_texts",
                  "code": "2c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Writing developed, well-structured texts on moderately complex or abstract topics that are socially or culturally relevant."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_content_organization_coherence_2d",
                  "indicatorKey": "precise_coherent_expression",
                  "code": "2d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Precise and coherent expression of intentions, hypotheses, supported opinions, arguments, narratives, or explanations, linking statements with appropriate transition words."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_writing_process_revision",
              "criterionKey": "writing_process_and_revision",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Writing Process and Revision"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses feedback and writing strategies consistently and effectively to revise and refine content, structure, clarity, and accuracy throughout the writing process."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_process_revision_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "self_regulated_learning_strategies",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote second-language autonomy."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_process_revision_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_process_revision_2e",
                  "indicatorKey": "identify_and_correct_common_errors",
                  "code": "2e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of appropriate strategies to identify and correct errors related to common spelling, grammar, syntax, and punctuation rules."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_process_revision_2f",
                  "indicatorKey": "evident_progress_writing",
                  "code": "2f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Evident progress in writing skills based on strategies and feedback."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_writing_language_use",
              "criterionKey": "language_use",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Language Use (Accuracy and Range)"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses a range of grammatical forms, verb tenses, and vocabulary with general control and precision, allowing ideas to be expressed clearly and effectively on moderately complex or abstract topics."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_language_use_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "range_of_grammatical_forms",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of a range of grammatical forms and complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_language_use_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "varied_vocabulary",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of varied vocabulary to communicate."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_writing_language_use_2e",
                  "indicatorKey": "correct_common_errors",
                  "code": "2e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of appropriate strategies to identify and correct errors related to common spelling, grammar, syntax, and punctuation rules."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "skillKey": "reinvestment",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Reinvestment"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_reinvestment_use_of_strategies",
              "criterionKey": "use_of_strategies",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Use of Strategies"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses reading or listening strategies judiciously and effectively to process texts, overcome comprehension obstacles, and identify relevant ideas for reinvestment."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "self_regulated_learning_strategies",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote second-language autonomy."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_3a",
                  "indicatorKey": "judicious_reading_listening_strategies",
                  "code": "3a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of judicious use of reading or listening strategies, taking into account the purpose and potential obstacles to reading or listening."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_reinvestment_processing",
              "criterionKey": "processing",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Processing"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Selects and processes main and supporting ideas or components from the source text accurately and precisely, identifying information or conventions that are relevant for reinvestment on moderately complex or abstract topics."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_reinvestment_processing_3b",
                  "indicatorKey": "accurate_precise_processing",
                  "code": "3b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Accurate processing, in oral or written form, of the components or the main and supporting ideas of texts on moderately complex or abstract topics of social or cultural relevance."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l3_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas",
              "criterionKey": "reinvestment_of_new_and_creative_ideas",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Reinvestment of New and Creative Ideas"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Integrates new ideas, personal reflections, and opinions coherently and precisely, demonstrating clear understanding of the source text and adapting the response to the communicative context."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the situation or communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_3c",
                  "indicatorKey": "precise_new_creative_analytical_ideas",
                  "code": "3c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Precise oral or written expression of new, creative, or analytical ideas, drawing on elements from the source text."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l3_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_3d",
                  "indicatorKey": "precise_coherent_response_text",
                  "code": "3d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Production of a precise and coherent oral, written, or media text in response to the source text, while respecting the components of the communication context."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },

    {
      "levelKey": "level_4",
      "labelByLanguage": {
        "en": "Level 4"
      },
      "cefrLabel": "C1",
      "skillGroups": [
        {
          "skillKey": "oral_interaction",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Oral Interaction"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_oral_clarity_coherence",
              "criterionKey": "clarity_and_coherence",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Clarity and Coherence"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Expresses ideas clearly, precisely, and with nuance, with fluency and autonomy, structuring discourse effectively and using appropriate transition words to sustain and develop ideas."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_clarity_coherence_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the situation or communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_clarity_coherence_1a",
                  "indicatorKey": "clear_fluent_nuanced_expression",
                  "code": "1a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Clear, fluent, and nuanced expression of arguments, interpretations, narratives, or in-depth, personalized explanations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_clarity_coherence_1e",
                  "indicatorKey": "fluent_interaction_complex_topics",
                  "code": "1e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Fluent interaction in varied communication contexts on complex topics."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_clarity_coherence_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "wide_range_grammatical_forms",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of a wide range of grammatical forms and complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_clarity_coherence_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "varied_precise_vocabulary",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of varied and precise vocabulary to communicate."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_oral_participation_interaction_responses",
              "criterionKey": "participation_interaction_strategies_and_responses",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Participation, Interaction Strategies, and Responses"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Engages autonomously and confidently in interaction, using interaction strategies flexibly and effectively to sustain, deepen, and enrich exchanges, and responding in nuanced, relevant, and purposeful ways."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1f",
                  "indicatorKey": "autonomous_strategic_interaction",
                  "code": "1f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Judicious and autonomous use of strategies to ensure the flow of ideas and to sustain the interaction."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1c",
                  "indicatorKey": "precise_coherent_nuanced_questions_answers",
                  "code": "1c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Precise, coherent, and nuanced formulation of questions and answers during interactions."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1d",
                  "indicatorKey": "fluent_relevant_reactions",
                  "code": "1d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Fluent and relevant reactions and responses to what the other person says."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_participation_interaction_responses_1e",
                  "indicatorKey": "fluent_interaction_complex_topics",
                  "code": "1e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Fluent interaction in varied communication contexts on complex topics."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_participation_interaction_responses_0g",
                  "indicatorKey": "active_effective_collaboration",
                  "code": "0g",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Active and effective collaboration."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_participation_interaction_responses_0f",
                  "indicatorKey": "openness_respect_curiosity",
                  "code": "0f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of openness, respect, and curiosity toward other cultures."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_oral_language_comprehensibility",
              "criterionKey": "language_and_comprehensibility",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Language and Comprehensibility"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Pronunciation, grammar, and vocabulary are precise, nuanced, and flexible, enabling clear, fluent, and nuanced communication on complex or abstract topics with minimal effort for interlocutors."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_language_comprehensibility_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "wide_range_grammatical_forms",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of a wide range of grammatical forms and complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_language_comprehensibility_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "varied_precise_vocabulary",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of varied and precise vocabulary to communicate."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_language_comprehensibility_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "effective_use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Effective use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_language_comprehensibility_1g",
                  "indicatorKey": "clear_precise_pronunciation",
                  "code": "1g",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Clear and precise pronunciation with appropriate intonation and pace."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_oral_progress_feedback",
              "criterionKey": "demonstrates_progress_based_on_strategies_and_feedback",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Demonstrates Progress Based on Strategies and Feedback"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Demonstrates autonomous, reflective, and strategic use of feedback and learning strategies to continuously refine and enhance oral interaction over time."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_progress_feedback_1h",
                  "indicatorKey": "evident_progress_oral_skills",
                  "code": "1h",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Evident progress in oral skills based on strategies and feedback."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_progress_feedback_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "effective_self_regulated_learning",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Effective use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote second-language autonomy."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_oral_progress_feedback_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "effective_use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Effective use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "skillKey": "writing_process",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Writing Process"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_writing_content_organization_coherence",
              "criterionKey": "content_organization_coherence",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Content, Organization, and Coherence"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Selects, develops, and organizes ideas with precision and nuance to communicate a clear, coherent, and well-structured message adapted to purpose, audience, and complex communication contexts."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_content_organization_coherence_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_content_organization_coherence_2a",
                  "indicatorKey": "judicious_choice_of_ideas_complex",
                  "code": "2a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Judicious choice of ideas that fit the writing topic in varied and complex situations."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_content_organization_coherence_2b",
                  "indicatorKey": "effective_reasoned_planning",
                  "code": "2b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Effective and well-reasoned planning of ideas and text structure."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_content_organization_coherence_2c",
                  "indicatorKey": "in_depth_well_structured_writing",
                  "code": "2c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "In-depth and well-structured writing on complex or abstract topics that are socially and culturally relevant."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_content_organization_coherence_2d",
                  "indicatorKey": "precise_nuanced_coherent_expression",
                  "code": "2d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Precise, nuanced, and coherent expression of interpretations, arguments, narratives, or in-depth explanations, linking statements with appropriate transition words."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_writing_process_revision",
              "criterionKey": "writing_process_and_revision",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Writing Process and Revision"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses feedback and writing strategies autonomously, strategically, and reflectively to revise, refine, and enhance content, structure, clarity, and accuracy throughout the writing process."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_process_revision_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "effective_self_regulated_learning",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Effective use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote second-language autonomy."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_process_revision_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "effective_use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Effective use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_process_revision_2e",
                  "indicatorKey": "identify_and_correct_errors",
                  "code": "2e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of appropriate strategies to identify and correct errors related to spelling, grammar, syntax, and punctuation rules."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_process_revision_2f",
                  "indicatorKey": "evident_progress_writing",
                  "code": "2f",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Evident progress in writing skills based on strategies and feedback."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_writing_language_use",
              "criterionKey": "language_use",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Language Use (Accuracy and Range)"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses grammatical forms, verb tenses, and vocabulary with precision, flexibility, and nuance, enabling clear, accurate, and sophisticated written communication on complex or abstract topics."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_language_use_0c",
                  "indicatorKey": "wide_range_grammatical_forms",
                  "code": "0c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Understanding and use of a wide range of grammatical forms and complex syntactic structures."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_language_use_0d",
                  "indicatorKey": "varied_precise_vocabulary",
                  "code": "0d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of varied and precise vocabulary to communicate."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_writing_language_use_2e",
                  "indicatorKey": "correct_errors_spelling_grammar_syntax",
                  "code": "2e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Use of appropriate strategies to identify and correct errors related to spelling, grammar, syntax, and punctuation rules."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "skillKey": "reinvestment",
          "labelByLanguage": {
            "en": "Reinvestment"
          },
          "criteria": [
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_reinvestment_use_of_strategies",
              "criterionKey": "use_of_strategies",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Use of Strategies"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Uses reading or listening strategies autonomously, flexibly, and strategically to process complex texts, address comprehension challenges, and identify ideas that can be reinvested effectively."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_0a",
                  "indicatorKey": "effective_self_regulated_learning",
                  "code": "0a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Effective use of self-regulated learning strategies that promote second-language autonomy."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_0e",
                  "indicatorKey": "effective_use_of_resources_and_tools",
                  "code": "0e",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Effective use of print and digital resources and tools for comprehension, production, revision, and editing."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_reinvestment_use_of_strategies_3a",
                  "indicatorKey": "judicious_reading_listening_strategies",
                  "code": "3a",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Demonstration of judicious use of reading or listening strategies, taking into account the purpose and potential obstacles to reading or listening."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_reinvestment_processing",
              "criterionKey": "processing",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Processing"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Selects, analyzes, and processes main and supporting ideas or components from the source text with precision and nuance, identifying information or conventions that are most relevant for effective reinvestment."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_reinvestment_processing_3b",
                  "indicatorKey": "accurate_processing_complex_texts",
                  "code": "3b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Accurate processing, in oral or written form, of the components or the main and supporting ideas of texts on complex or abstract topics of social or cultural relevance."
                  }
                }
              ]
            },
            {
              "criterionId": "l4_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas",
              "criterionKey": "reinvestment_of_new_and_creative_ideas",
              "labelByLanguage": {
                "en": "Reinvestment of New and Creative Ideas"
              },
              "descriptionByLanguage": {
                "en": "Integrates new ideas, interpretations, and personal insights with precision and nuance, demonstrating deep understanding of the source text and adapting the response effectively to complex communicative contexts."
              },
              "successIndicators": [
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_0b",
                  "indicatorKey": "adaptation_to_context",
                  "code": "0b",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Appropriate adaptation of discourse to the situation or communication context."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_3c",
                  "indicatorKey": "precise_nuanced_new_ideas",
                  "code": "3c",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Precise and nuanced oral or written expression of new, creative, or analytical ideas, drawing on elements from the source text."
                  }
                },
                {
                  "indicatorId": "l4_reinvestment_new_creative_ideas_3d",
                  "indicatorKey": "in_depth_personalized_response_text",
                  "code": "3d",
                  "labelByLanguage": {
                    "en": "Production of an in-depth, personalized, and coherent oral, written, or media text in response to the source text, while respecting the components of the communication context."
                  }
                }
              ]
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}